Straw Slop

You said that predicting some AI automation means wanting to fire all programmers.

The reasoning

AI discussions are especially prone to collapsing nuanced positions into tribal ones.

Someone says:

“Generative AI could significantly reduce the time required for some art-production tasks.”

It becomes:

“So you think artists are obsolete.”

Someone says:

“Current AI systems still have important reliability problems.”

It becomes:

“So you're saying AI is useless.”

Someone says:

“I don't think training on publicly accessible images is inherently equivalent to theft.”

It becomes:

“So artists deserve no rights.”

The substitute argument may be easier to condemn—but it isn't the argument that was made.

Example

A: “I think AI will automate portions of software development.”

B: “So programmers should all be fired and replaced by robots?”

A didn't say that.

Underlying fallacy

Based on Straw man

All fallacies