The reasoning
AI discussions are especially prone to collapsing nuanced positions into tribal ones.
Someone says:
“Generative AI could significantly reduce the time required for some art-production tasks.”
It becomes:
“So you think artists are obsolete.”
Someone says:
“Current AI systems still have important reliability problems.”
It becomes:
“So you're saying AI is useless.”
Someone says:
“I don't think training on publicly accessible images is inherently equivalent to theft.”
It becomes:
“So artists deserve no rights.”
The substitute argument may be easier to condemn—but it isn't the argument that was made.
Example
A: “I think AI will automate portions of software development.”
B: “So programmers should all be fired and replaced by robots?”
A didn't say that.
