The reasoning
This fallacy ignores the degree to which AI is used.
AI might be used as a generative fill to remove a blemish on a texture, or it might be used to churn out hundreds of textures.
The distinction is relevant, and generalizing an entire thing as "AI slop" regardless of the degree is intellectually lazy.
Example
“It turns out the artist used AI to increase the resolution of a single texture. The whole game is therefore slop.”
