Slop and Bailey

You said that AI had a specific consequence, and when challenged, reframed your position to one that was more general and easier to defend.

The reasoning

The person espousing this fallacy first makes a bold claim to point out how AI is uniquely bad, e.g. that it displaces artists, steals jobs, or its data centers waste water. This is the "motte." When countered, the arguer retreats to the "bailey," arguments that reframe the debate around generalities that has better evidence (e.g. economic disruption or climate change, generally). This bait-and-switch is a fallacy because it doesn't address what was originally claimed or show how AI is uniquely blamable.

Example

“Your use of AI replaced artists.”

“Our illustrator worked on this image and chose to use the AI tool.”

“Well, AI has environmental costs.”

Underlying fallacy

Related to Motte-and-bailey fallacy / shifting the claim

All fallacies